Need a shot in the arm for your homeschool?

Get Thrive Together, a monthly email that brings you:

  • the best of the homeschool blogosphere,
  • current happenings in education-land,
  • and great quotes that will refresh your homeschool mama mind.

Yes, I want Thrive Together!

* indicates required



Recent Posts

Some links on this site are affiliate links. A percentage of qualifying purchases support this site. 

HFC is powered by SiteGround.

Subscribe to our Mailing List

Get the news right in your inbox!

Privacy Policy

Beauty in the Word – Ch. 1 Child, Person, Teacher

Beauty in the Word – Ch. 1 Child, Person, Teacher

This is part of the ongoing discussion with Cindy at Ordo-Amoris.

Stratford Caldecott devotes this chapter to describing the nature of the personhood of the child and how teacher and child interrelate with one another and with God.

Child-Centered vs Teacher-Centered Approach to Education

Caldecott points out fairly the devastating effects of over-emphasizing either the child or the teacher/method/curriculum. “[Romantic] educators believe that too much rote learning and compulsion will turn children against education altogether—and in Catholic circles away from the church. Whereas, too much child-centered education results in “such absurdities as pupils being given certificates of recognition for ‘future achievements’ that may never happen and refusal to award low grades or admit failure…[resulting in] narcissism, overconfidence, and vacuous sentimentality” (19).

So how do we find a new balance, a new approach that does justice to the positive in both of these methods of education? (20)

For Caldecott, the answer lies in attending to a specifically Christian definition of what it means to be a child. This is why the public school system can never get education right.  It’s not just a middle-ground between child- or teacher-centered education we should seek, it’s that government bureaucrats can only define the child in psychological, social, or developmental terms, certainly never spiritual.  Caldecott says the child shows the image of God better than the adult–a sort-of more pure form of human. “It is the central image of man, a sign and pointer towards his origin and the purity of his original being” (27).

At first, I was skeptical of this claim, being a firm believer that children are sinners just like the rest of us.  Anyone who’s ever parented through the terrible-twos can clearly see how ungodly even the cutest of children are.

Caldecott, thank goodness, says “This is not to romanticize or idealize childhood, but to understand it in the light of a new fact: the Incarnation of the second person of the divine Trinity” (26).  That Christ came to us in the form of a child–a fetus no less–shows us that even that bit of humanity is redeemed and within reach of the eternal, ever-loving God of the Universe.  The Lord of Heaven and Earth humbled himself to the point of total dependence on earthly parents.  Yikes.

But children do have a strange way of seeing the world.  Call it innocence, call it purity, call it trust.  In all our work to form them into adults like us, sometimes we fail to realize how different children really are from us.  We must pay attention to the fact that there is something inherent in childhood that Christ wants us to imitate, when He said, “Truly, I say to you, whoever does not receive the kingdom of God like a child shall not enter it” (Mark 10:15).

I love what Cindy said about “the way we really learn in sprints and spurts and rests,” and, “Learning is ALWAYS individual because of the nature of growth.”  This is a radical idea even to homeschooling parents.  Don’t we “need” to be doing 5 lessons per week, for X number of weeks, to “stay on track?”  No, there’s nothing wrong with hitting benchmarks on the way to long-term goals, but LIFE happens, and people aren’t machines.

I also like the way the veteran journalism teacher says it in this new HSLDA video on Common Core.  “They’re not apples, they’re people!”  That is, they’re not objects to be traded or consumed, or pushed along an assembly line toward a college degree and successful career.  They are living beings with hearts and dreams, who trust easily and are purer than ourselves.

So how shall we teach such beings?  I’m sure Caldecott will spend the rest of the book fleshing this out but he says, “If attention to the child is the key to the teacher’s success, it is the child’s own quality of attention that is the key to the learning process” (30).

The teacher’s purpose is to help the student “attend” to truth.  “Attention is desire: it is the desire for light, for truth, for understanding, for possession” (30). If the nature of a child is to trust and believe more easily than us, we simply need to direct their trusting and belief toward truth.

We’ll see what Caldecott has in store for us in Chapter 2.

Rhiannon Kutzer

All posts

No Comments

Leave a Reply

Nice to meet you!

Nice to meet you!

I’m Rhiannon.

You can call me Rhi for short (as in “rewrite”). I’m a fiercely independent homeschooling mom of five, a Navy wife of almost 13 years, and a creator of various things: articles, a monthly newsletter, quilts, furniture, and the occasional knitted scarf. This is the site where I write about our homeschool journey and news and happenings in the homeschool world. more about me.

Rhiannon

Subscribe & Follow

Popular Links

Let’s Thrive Together!

Need a shot in the arm for your homeschool? Get Thrive Together, a monthly email that brings you:

--the best of the homeschool blogosphere,
--current homeschool news,
--and great quotes that will refresh your homeschool mama mind.

Latest Posts

Instagram

  • Happy 119th birthday, U.S. Submarine Force! Y’all know how to party here in the Submarine Capital of the World. Thanks to the lovely and talented @alisanomaly for taming my locks. And thank you to my handsome sailor for a fun night out! #milspouse
  • First attempt at bubbles. Don’t know what I’m doing, but we needed to get laundry little more organized and this was a fun way to do it. #procrastination #watercolor #bravewriterlifestyle #homeschool #chores
  • #happyplace
  • Just got my new tank to support my favorite new #startup 😍. Y’all should check out @smarthernews SmartHerNews.com
  • #winning #homeschool #cakeforlunch #bravewriterlifestyle #charlottemasonirl
  • When your 7yo wakes up and wants to bake a Pokémon cake before you’ve had enough coffee, saying “Yes!” Is an opportunity to bring enchantment, independence, empowerment, and fun into what would otherwise be an unremarkable homeschool day of blah.
.
Here are 2 CM principles to accompany, so you don’t break out in hives at the prospect of a kitchen tornado: “(a) The children, not the teachers, are the responsible persons; they do the work by self-effort. (b) The teachers give sympathy and occasionally elucidate, sum up or enlarge, but the actual work is done by the scholars” (vol. 6, p. 6).
.
I had to resist 1) Saying “No,” in the first place. I literally had to say to myself, “Okay, this is what we’re doing today.” 2) The urge to turn baking into a whiteboard lesson on fractions. That would have killed the enchantment quicker than snuffing out a candle. We *may* talk *after* we bake. 3) The urge to correct or do it for her. If the cake fails, it fails, and we will talk about why.
.
That is all, happy Thursday!
.
#homeschool #homeschoolmom #charlottemason #charlottemasonirl #Charlottemasonliving #education #bravewriterlifestyle #charlottemasonhomeschool #homeschooling

Follow @rhikutzer

Twitter Feed

×